We
describe our experience in rehabilitating back injuries by following the course
of a 25 year old competitive ski racer on the Women's Pro Ski Tour. Her experience
may serve as a useful guide to those skiers who fly off bumps a little too early,
who land a little too late, who twist where they meant to turn, and who end the
day more than a little sore.
Unfortunately,
one of the most common injuries sustained in sports is an injury to the spine.
It is second only to the common cold as the most frequent problem seen by physicians.
Back injuries in ski racers are often career ending and are typically due to a
variety of reasons in addition to a ski fall. The reasons include poor postural
positioning, muscle imbalances, decreased flexibility, improper lifting and training
mechanics, and even the stresses of excessive travel with long plane and car rides
and hauling luggage.
Rehabilitation
following a back injury requires a careful assessment of the injury and predisposing
factors followed by aggressive muscle and postural training if racing is to resume
early and at top level.
HISTORY
C.S. was competitively
ski racing for a number of years. She had a history of minor injuries until sustaining
a complete tear of her anterior cruciate ligament in a twisting fall. She had
ACL reconstruction at The Stone Clinic in San Francisco in the late spring and
returned to competitive skiing by the fall. Three months later, she developed
sharp low back pain after ski training one afternoon. The symptoms included pain
with forward bending, sneezing, and any impact like running or jumping. She also
reported intermittent pain in the right leg to the calf level. Her lumbar muscles
were stiff with limitation into forward and lateral bending. A magnetic resonance
image scan (MRI) demonstrated a minimal disc bulge on the right side of the lumber
spine. Her diagnosis was a tear of the annulus that contains the nucleus pulposus
of the disc, causing the disc to bulge against the nerve root. The pressure on
the nerve led to muscle spasm and back pain. Her period of "rest" led to spinal
muscle weakness, decreased disc nutrition and mobility, and poor spinal mechanics.
EXAMINATION
Upon initial evaluation,
C.S. was unable to ski race without pain and after 2 or 3 runs was unable to ski
at all due to pain. On examination she had an unstable, extended posture during
standing and gait. Her pain free functional range of motion at the lumbar spine
was limited in both flexion and extension. She had excellent strength of her back
extensor muscles but only fair strength of her abdominal muscles. In her pelvic
region, her proprioception, which is the ability to recognize what the body is
doing, was poor. She demonstrated good hamstring flexibility but had tight upper
quads, hip flexors, and hip rotators (piriformis muscles).
REHABILITATION
PROGRAM
When
constructing the rehabilitation program, a few things in particular needed to
be taken into consideration. First, she should be able to return to professional
ski racing with minimal pain. Second, she had to be able to find, stabilize and
maintain good neutral positioning or posture of her spine during all exercises,
so that it would carry over into her skiing. Third, she had to learn an optimal
stabilization program to prevent recurrence.
Inflammation
and muscle spasm reduction, pain reduction, and range of motion exercises were
initiated immediately. Inflammation and pain control were treated with a low dose
of anti-inflammatories, soft tissue massage and mobilization, icing, and passive
stretching into specific ranges concentrating on contract-relax modes. Correction
of soft tissue and bony abnormalities by manual mobilization and manipulation
is a crucial part of inflammation and pain relief. Instruction on finding functional
neutral position of the spine was also a critical component to reduce exacerbation
of the symptoms.
The
rehabilitation goals were fourfold. First was to determine her pain-free functional
range of motion. This is the range of motion that does not reproduce pain into
forward bending, extending and other various postures. As the rehabilitation program
progressed, this available range should increase accordingly. Second was to use
therapeutic modalities such as ultrasound and electrical stimulation, as well
as manual therapy techniques to control the inflammation and improve her overall
mobility. Third, pelvis and trunk proprioception should be trained through stabilization
exercises to gain more control over her movement patterns. Finally, the endurance,
strength, and power of the legs and trunk should be increased to give her the
ability to maintain a functional position during skiing.
The
treatment plan began with posture and proprioceptive training of the pelvic girdle.
Endurance, strength and power training of the trunk musculature was also initiated,
as well as a general flexibility program. Proper standing, sitting, and movement
positioning were taught immediately. She started by standing in an unstable extended
spine position (Fig. 1).
She was shown the proper functional position that would be reinforced during her
training sessions (Fig 2a,
2b). Use of a stick for
proprioceptive response enabled the patient to understand and maintain proper
pelvic position while moving (Fig. 3a,
3b, 3c).
Once she was able to maintain her pelvic position with activity, resistance training
gradually progressed. The program concentrated on the endurance of the trunk musculature
by using low intensity, high repetition exercises.
EXERCISES
First, endurance
and strength of the spinal rotators, spinal extensors and abdominals increased
through the use of rhythmic stabilization and repeated contraction techniques.
That is, contracting into the areas of weakness (Fig. 4,
4b, 4c).
She maintained neutral position during the exercise when changes in position were
made by the practitioner. In a face down position, further strengthening was achieved
by performing diagonal extension exercises (Fig. 5).
Increasing endurance and strength would also increase her ability to maintain
a stable lumber position over an extended period of time.
Second,
isometrics were performed by contracting muscles into certain positions but without
moving (Fig. 6a, 6b,
6c). In particular, standing,
reaching overhead, and squatting were focused. Symmetrical squatting for leg strength
and postural control was then conducted (Fig. 7a,
7b). Heel wedges were used
to more correctly simulate the skiing motion and range that would be needed. She
was started without resistance and increased by adding weight as able.
A push and pull exercise
was next added to simulate day-to-day activities and further strengthen her while
moving forward and backward (Fig. 8).
Again, the focus was to be able to hold the optimal position of neutral throughout
the exercise.
As
she was going through this initial program, cardiovascular endurance training
was performed using a stationary bicycle. At this point, an interval, sprint bicycling
program was introduced and a VersaClimber program started (Fig. 11).
Road cycling on varying levels of terrain was also initiated while constantly
maintaining a good functional position.
The
next progression of the program involved using symmetrical squats with resistance
(Fig. 12). Adding resistance
forced the patient to adapt to outside forces that were somewhat regular but changing
due to the resistance provided by the practitioner. This was further advanced
and increased by using a balance board (Fig. 13a,
13b). The unstable surface
forced her to maintain a position of stability through movement much like that
needed in skiing.
Using
an exercise ball to apply changing forces helped aid in strength and endurance
training (Fig. 14). This
was performed in three standing positions while maintaining good position. The
force, direction, and speed was changed periodically.
The
next level of difficulty involved balance board squats with resistance from an
elastic tubing (Lifeline, Madison, WI) (Fig. 15).
She was to maintain her functional position while performing periodic sets of
high repetition with varying pull from different positions. This was particularly
beneficial when the resistance was from the sides (Fig. 16).
She was then able to simulate the arm and shoulder position necessary for ski
racing while maintaining her balance and position throughout the squat.
Finally, she added to her
cardiovascular and trunk endurance, strength and power by using a slide board.
She performed eight foot side to side glides while maintaining her functional
position (Fig. 17).
This step progression overlapped
as she was able to tolerate new and more difficult exercises. Less challenging
exercises were dropped as more intense exercises were added. This allowed the
program to maintain a high level of intensity, frequency, and duration each day
to give her rapid increases in certain specific components. She was treated 3-5
times per week for three weeks before she was allowed to resume skiing. After
two additional weeks, she returned to ski racing without incident.
The
importance of working with a rehabilitation team to help guide and progress a
well structured program is of paramount importance if one wants to return to a
high level of activity.
For
more information, e-mail Devin Wu at: devin@stoneclinic.com